Benjamin facepalmed.
"Oh my God! Is that really something to be proud of?"
"S-shut up! I know you wanted it. I saw you masturbating to me in the bathroom!"
"Gosh, you're really..."
He sighed and looked at her. No matter how excited she had been previously, she was still currently wincing in pain. He could feel her extremely tight vagina around his shaft, the tighter he had ever experienced. Adding to that the fact she impaled herself so violently on him, it was obvious it would be hurting. Even though he was still annoyed at her, the priority right now was to take care of her and help to relieve her pain.
"It hurts, right? Listen to me and bend down."
"It doesn't hurt, okay? It feels good, actually!"
"Hurry up!"
She was taken aback by his serious expression and obeyed him soon after, too spooked to refuse any further. She seldom saw her brother get upset and knew better than to disobey him when it happened.
When her head was in front of his, he took it into his hands and delicately kissed her, to her surprise. His goal was to make her focus on something else and he continued to give her small pecks, waiting for her to get used to them. Her expression slowly changed from amazement to affection and it didn't take long before she stuck her lips to his. Once there, she didn't move, going for a long kiss, her eyes full of love.
He used the opportunity to try inserting his tongue and she quickly reacted to it, entangling her own with his, the two of them playing like this for a long time. He let her try anything she was curious about and she happily took the opportunity given to her, exploring everywhere in his mouth, sucking his tongue, licking his gums or even sucking his lips. It seemed his goal of making her forget about the pain was successful since there wasn't any remnant of suffering on her face, completely replaced by love and lust.
Eventually, he separated from her but when he did so, she went for him instead, plunging on him to kiss him again. She continued to kiss him many times, not giving them much of a break. She also sometimes whispered in between two kisses.
"It feels good. I love kissing. I love you, Ben. I'm so happy you're my brother. I love you. I love you."
She was clearly high on her feelings because her attitude was very different from usual. Sensing this, he let her do whatever she wanted, waiting until she calmed down. It took a long time, which she used fully to her advantage. On top of kissing him in all kinds of different ways and places, she also licked him here and there, mostly on his face but also on his neck and shoulders. She also nibbled on his earlobes, sent her tongue into his ears, and caressed his hair plenty. She had always been a very curious girl and proved it once again today, trying anything she could think of.
Eventually, she was satisfied enough to take a longer break. She raised her upper body back and admired him, her twat still full of his dick all the while. Seeing him with her kissing marks and saliva everywhere, she shivered in excitement. Her trembling seemed to remind her of what was inserted inside her because she moved her waist around, moaning at the feeling.
"How do you feel, Chloe?"
"It doesn't hurt now... Say, I can't hold back anymore. Can we go all the way, please, Ben?"
He stared at her tentative of doing her puppy eyes attack even though her expression was full of lust.
"Fine. But take your time to get used to it. Don't hurt yourself again, okay?"
"Yes!"
She beamed, almost not believing her luck. To think the brother of her fantasies, the one she masturbated to all of the time, would allow her to have sex with him! This was a dream come true, no, one of her fantasies come true yet again! Adding to this the scene in the bathroom and the loss of her virginity, this was the best day ever. She would have played the lottery had she any money left!
She slowly raised her waist until his glans almost exited her insides and dropped herself down on him again. His penis parted her pussy walls and ground against her creases, only to poke at her cervix in the end. It felt so good that she came on the spot, moaning her orgasm and releasing a flood of juices on his cock. Darn, he was so incredibly big inside her. She felt like she was inserting a rod inside her cunt. She was so full of him! She looked down and could see his large member making a bump over her pelvis. This view was so exciting. She then checked her brother's expression and seeing him smiling tenderly, she had to ask him.
"How does it feel for you, Ben? I-I'm super tight, right?"
He saw her looking a bit unsure and reassured her.
"You're incredibly tight. It feels like you're going tear my penis out whenever you move."
She grinned widely and immediately acted on his word, sending her waist up again. He hadn't lied and her pussy was so tight the sensation was heavenly. His whole member was stimulated every time her hips were going up and down and it was fortunate she was so wet because there was no way any movement would have been possible otherwise. On top of that, even when she took him fully inside her, he still had more than a third of his cock unable to enter her.
She continued riding him and came again on her third thrust, looking to be a bit frustrated by it.
"Aahh! Haah, haah. Hey, why aren't coming, Ben?"
This was such a typical question of a girl who got all her sexual knowledge from watching porn. Not only did she only thrust three times so far, but he also came barely a few minutes ago. Even if she was incredibly tight and wet, he was still far from a second shot. It was a perfect opportunity to tease her, though, and he didn't hesitate to take it.
"I wonder why? Why don't you show me what you can do? Didn't you say you would fuck me hard when you were masturbating after the poker game?"
"Y-you heard that?"
"I sure did, baby sister. Can't wait to see that happening. If you can, that is."
"I can! I'll show you! You won't be laughing for long!"
"Oh, I'm so scared!"
"Grrr."
She moved her waist up again and resumed her movements, a determined expression on her face.